Search
Soft daylight illuminates worn oak floors, original wood windows and a built-in bookcase in an empty South Pasadena Craftsman living room.

South Pasadena's Former Caltrans Houses Show How Buyers Price a Fixer

In late 2024, South Pasadena put five houses on the market that had sat empty for years. Caltrans had bought them for a freeway that was never built. All five sold above their asking prices. The premiums ranged from about 6% to about 38%, and the size of each premium followed condition in the opposite direction from what most buyers would guess. The house in the best shape won the smallest premium. The three-unit property with boarded-up windows won the largest.

For anyone comparing South Pasadena with its neighbors, that pattern is more useful than a median price. It shows that an "over asking" headline tells you how a home was listed. It tells you much less about what the home was worth.

How the Five Former 710 Homes Sold

The City of South Pasadena bought the five properties from Caltrans for $165,700 in total. It then sold them at market prices, and the proceeds went to affordable housing. The city set an October 25, 2024 deadline for offers. According to LAist, thousands of people toured the houses on Fairview, Fremont and Meridian avenues that October. The table below shows the asking and final prices LAist published in February 2025 for sales that closed in late 2024 and early 2025. The percentages are calculated from those figures.

Property What it was Asking price Sale price Premium over ask
726 Meridian Ave. Three units about $1.25 million $1.72 million about 38%
217 Fremont Ave. 3 bed, 3 bath about $1.2 million $1.45 million about 21%
216 Fairview Ave. 3 bed, 1 bath, large porch $1.076 million $1.274 million about 18%
225 Fremont Ave. 4 bed, 2 bath about $1.2 million $1.377 million about 15%
1707 Meridian Ave. 2 bedrooms $949,000 $1,007,000 about 6%

Combined, the five asked for roughly $5.7 million and brought in about $6.8 million. LAist reported that the city placed the proceeds in its Affordable Housing Trust Fund toward 15 new units.

The Best-Kept House Drew the Smallest Premium

LAist described the houses as having "boarded up windows, damaged floors and peeling paint." It said 1707 Meridian appeared to be in the best shape of the five when its reporter visited. That house sold for $58,000 over its asking price. The three-unit property at 726 Meridian sold for nearly half a million dollars over. A real estate agent quoted by LAist said 217 Fremont "needs a lot of love, but offers a lot of opportunity," and it went for a quarter of a million over.

A two-bedroom house in decent condition is easy to value. The asking price can sit close to what the house is worth, so competing buyers have little room to bid it up. A worn three-unit property is harder to value, because its price depends on what a buyer plans to do with it. One bidder sees three rents. Another sees a family compound or a long restoration project. The asking price on 726 Meridian left a wide gap between how the property looked on the day of the tour and what it could become, and competing buyers closed most of that gap.

In this round, the premium measured how much potential the asking price had left out. Condition had little to do with it.

Finished Homes on the Same Streets Still Sold for More

If over-asking bids had simply been buyers overpaying, the Caltrans houses would have sold for more than finished homes nearby. They did not. LAist compared the sales with two others nearby: a duplex on Diamond Avenue that sold for $1.87 million in July, and a four-bedroom, two-bath house on Ramona Avenue that sold for $1.57 million a few weeks before its February 2025 story.

Put those next to the table. The three-unit property at 726 Meridian sold for $1.72 million, about $150,000 below the Diamond Avenue duplex despite having one more unit. The four-bedroom, two-bath house at 225 Fremont sold for $1.377 million, about $190,000 below the Ramona Avenue house with the same bedroom and bath count. Even after the bidding, buyers stayed below the finished comparables. The remaining gap roughly marks what they expected to spend on floors, windows, systems and time.

Buyers paid well above the list price and stopped short of what a move-in-ready home on the next block had sold for.

Eight More Homes on the Same Blocks

On March 4, 2026, the City Council approved agreements to buy and sell 12 more Caltrans properties, according to the South Pasadena Review. The city announced that eight of them would go on the market starting June 9, 2026. The Pasadena Star-News listed them as 1131 Columbia Street, known as the Columbia House; 530 and 534 Orange Grove Avenue; 901 Bonita Drive; 1037 and 1039 Grevelia Street; 808 and 822 Valley View Road; and a home on Prospect Avenue.

The Columbia House is on the city's Inventory of Historic Resources as a Craftsman built in 1910. The Star-News reported that more than 60 South Pasadena properties were once taken for the freeway project. The city's official record of the program is on its Caltrans Surplus Properties page.

The 2024 sales give a way to read this group. Paired addresses like the two on Orange Grove, the two on Grevelia and the two on Valley View are the kind of property the first round priced most generously. In 2024, a buyer with a plan for extra units or a restoration bid well past the list price. The Columbia House is a different case. A designated 1910 Craftsman suits a buyer who wants an old house restored as a historic house, and that buyer values it differently from one counting rentable units.

Reading an Over-Asking Number Anywhere in Town

The same logic applies well beyond the Caltrans streets. When a South Pasadena sale is reported at a large premium over asking, it helps to ask two questions before treating it as a comparable. First, how close was the list price to the value of a finished home? Second, how much of the property's value depended on a buyer's plans rather than its condition on the day it sold?

A modest premium on a well-kept house may mean the asking price was accurate. A large premium on a worn property with more than one unit may mean the asking price left room on purpose, or simply that the property was hard to price. Both kinds of sale can end up below a renovated house a few blocks away, as 726 Meridian and 225 Fremont did. For a buyer writing an offer, the finished comparable is the ceiling. The asking price on a property like these is where the bidding starts.

For more on how homes trade across town, our South Pasadena neighborhood page and buyer resources carry the broader picture.

A Few Direct Questions

Where are the former Caltrans homes in South Pasadena? The first five were on Meridian, Fremont and Fairview avenues. The 2026 group is on Columbia Street, Orange Grove Avenue, Bonita Drive, Grevelia Street, Valley View Road and Prospect Avenue.

Who is selling them? The City of South Pasadena, which acquires the vacant homes from Caltrans and lists them for sale.

Where does the sale money go? To affordable housing. LAist reported that the roughly $6.8 million from the first five sales went into the city's Affordable Housing Trust Fund toward 15 units.

If you are weighing an offer on one of these 710-corridor houses, or on any South Pasadena home where the asking price and the finished comparables tell different stories, I would be glad to go through the numbers with you street by street. Nichole Dunville represents buyers and sellers of historic, character and luxury homes across the San Gabriel Valley. Let's Connect.

Work With Nichole

Experience concierge-level service, expert strategy, and a personalized approach to real estate.

Follow Me on Instagram